Monday, November 16, 2026

11/28/73: an emergent whole of constituent moment forms (take 1)

Seastones album art, detail

Most of the scant few things written about this epic show refer to it on a spectrum between "endurance marathon" and "cosmic torture chamber." I beg to differ. This show rules and I wanted to listen to it again, ponder what it all means, and provide a bare overview of the music itself for the sake of those who may find something to love here but may be feeling timid about navigating two and a half of sheer weirdness. But be warned: there will be footnotes.

THE GIG

What this show even is has been historically murky. Thanks to both Ned Lagin's own account and GD scholar Melvin Backstrom's 2018 dissertation, I have learned a few things, and I highly recommend Backstrom's chapter on Seastones if you want to learn more about how these 1973-75 performances worked (or didn't work as intended, in many cases). [1] Mickey Hart agreed to participate in and/or decided to stage a benefit for the ashram of kundalini yoga teacher Sat Santokh Singh Khalsa, formerly known as Bert Kanegson, a GD family member and one-time manager [2]. Jerry Garcia was apparently also close with Santokh and, of course, was always down for a benefit. The venue was the newly-ish reopened Palace of Fine Arts Theatre, whose backstory as a building built for decay has a kind of inverse resonance with Lagin's own compositional ideas.

There is a memorable poster for the gig, with a nice story about how Hart and Garcia were surprised to find each other unexpectedly clean-shaven and dressed, respectively, in white and black when they arrived at the photo shoot.

courtesy jerrybase

Behind the scenes, Lagin, Lesh, Garcia, Hart, and a handful of others had been playing Lagin's electronic music at Hart's barn studio in Novato for about half a year. Lagin says that Garcia and Lesh had encouraged him to move to California for the express purpose of working on and performing his music with them. He arrived in April 1973. I am sure that no one reading this needs reminding of Garcia's contemporaneous activities ca mid-1973; how delighted must the various factions from the Grateful Dead, Merl Saunders, and Grisman/Rowan camps have been upon finding out that their golden boy was taking up another project? Nevertheless, their musical endeavors included working with elements of quadraphonic sound (Lesh's basses, as you may know, were wired for quad sound in 1973-74).

As Lagin tells it, when Hart billed this benefit show as "an experiment in quadraphonic sound" with Garcia, but declined to invite his fellow quadraphonic sound experimenters to participate, feelings were hurt and then soothed by expanding the duet to a kind-of quartet. Lagin participated in the music but not did not come onstage (as was his wont philosophically [3], although in this particular context it does also seem slightly passive aggressive?). Lesh apparently handled the quad sound mix (this involved a joystick) and deployed many of the pre-recorded synthesizer tracks. Backstrom reports (248) that the only other known documentation of this show is the invoice for the gear that Hart rented. 

The music was 2 1/2 hours of, well... I gather that a bit of it is an early iteration of Seastones, and a lot of it is improvised? But how much was improvised? What does improvisation even mean in this context? Lagin's explanation of his Seastones-related performances is that there was never intended to be any amount of "free" improv, that the music all had some degree of pre-planned structure or form, things happening by design that impacted what the musicians onstage were doing in the moment; but, this being the world of the Grateful Dead, of course, those plans only counted for so much.

Lagin: A third to a half of this concert had pre-recorded tapes, and all the pre-recorded tapes were Seastones tapes. So if you hear Grace [Slick; see below] or anybody else than you’re hearing Seastones. And if you hear Buchla or Moog or other synthesized stuff, you’re hearing Phil adjusting the mix at the board because those pre-recorded tapes were coming from the board and were being initiated or started and stopped by Phil or me up in the audience.

Backstrom: But you were also playing your Arp Odyssey live, right?

Lagin: Yes, directly into the board. (Backstrom 251)

So does that mean that one-half to two-thirds of this show isn't Seastones, then? Given that any recorded performance of Seastones would likely become 'accreted' into later performances of Seastones, then it's kind of all Seastones, right? Or something that was in the process of becoming some future version of Seastones? Right? Help?

THE TAPES

There are two source recordings for this. The first source, a 4cd set assembled and circulated in 1999 by D. Finney, was a mysterious document for a long time; since set included additional unrelated "filler" material, I don't think there was a clear consensus as to how the "11/28/73" pieces were related. The second source is the entire audience recording that provides the portion ("Seastones 3") on the Finney source (which is a higher gen copy), and was transferred and released in full in 2010 by the MOTB crew. Finney's "Seastones 4" is attributed to a different performance entirely (6/6/75) and, as far as I can tell, doesn't overlap with any of the music from 11/28/73. The Finney sbd provides the first 90 min of the 11/28/73 performance (there's a tape flip 46 minutes in with a 30 second gap can be patched with the MOTB aud), and the MOTB aud provides the final 50 minutes. The MOTB aud tape is missing the first 28 min of the show, but then runs complete through the end. Lossless Legs commenter Robman pointed out the overlaps a few years ago, and if I ever meet him, I owe him a drink.

The sbd is in stereo; the aud is mono and sounds pretty clear, although there's a lot of coughing and hushed whispering and giggling in spots (fair enough). The stereo sbd has a couple generations worth of hiss and is running a tad fast (or faster than the MOTB aud, anyway), but imho is still the better listening experience. Matrixing the two would be awesome, but as far as I could tell, there's no additionally audible stuff on the aud than what I could hear on the sbd. Backstrom only discusses the Finney source, not the MOTB source.

THE MUSIC

The show is 2 hours and 23 minutes, assuming there's not more from the start of the performance that's not on the Finney sbd. My analysis doesn't follow either the Finney or MOTB tracking; to relish the full experience, I made my own composite of the two sources in Audacity as one big track, so these notations are timestamps in relation to the entire uninterrupted performance. Also, being super precise is not my point here (and probably impossible given the nature of the instrumentation): this is just a rough roadmap to who's playing when.

0-6 min - Garcia & Lagin, a pretty gentle start.

6-13 - just Lagin

13-18 - Lagin & Hart (maybe Hart enters earlier? it's hard to tell)

18-29 - Garcia & Hart, who is mostly playing a gong (although maybe this is pre-recorded?)

29-34 - Garcia solo (more or less). Hearing Garcia out in space like this, first over a droning gong and then alone against the void, is particularly magical.

34-40 - Garcia & Lesh (apparently, this is a pre-recorded tape of Lesh's bass)

40-46 - Lesh & Lagin. imho this part sounds more abrasive and more like a 1974 "Phil & Ned" set.

46-82 - I think this long stretch is all Lagin and/or Seastones tapes. It begins with voices (Grace Slick's exclaiming "seastones!" then Garcia's), and incorporates a range of pre-recorded stuff including bagpipes, synthesized orchestral strings (from the Arp Odyssey, I presume), running water, birds, frogs, prepared piano, thunder, church bells, and finally a long stretch of Indian tanpura(s). My guess is that the percussion sounds (various metallophones?) in here are recordings, not Mickey in real time, but I don't know. Garcia rejoins towards the end of this, but doesn't get going for a few minutes.

82-98 - Garcia & Lagin. Garcia returns (playing over the tanpura drone!) and takes the lead, Lagin building up the textural density behind him. Garcia even gets a little Tiger-y in here and the effect is amazing. I absolutely love this part.

98-105 - just Lagin? - heavy oceanic drone, serious "alarms going off on a submarine" vibes.

105-111 - Garcia & Lagin, now with Lagin now playing more atonal melodic lines (on the Arp?) rather than heavy texture.

112-143 - Garcia & Hart are the focus of the final section, with some Lagin cameos. For me, the magic dissipates here, and I don't think it's just ear fatigue. Hart appears to be playing a standard drum kit here and he finds his way into a "rock drum solo" headspace that feels a little like sitting next to someone who's tapping their foot incessantly. Meh. Garcia moves more to the fore for the final stretch, particularly the last 8 minutes, which features some sublime wahwah/slide guitar perfection (you know that part from the 11/11/73 Dark Star that you wish went on forever? here you go). It ends with a thump, the taper intones "holy shit," and the announcer says, "Mickey Hart...and Jerry Garcia."

I assume that Garcia is only playing when it sounds explicitly like Jerry Garcia's guitar, and that Hart is only playing when it sounds like "live" percussion or drums. But it's impossible to be sure of this. By Lagin's telling, in 1974 Garcia sometimes performed through Lagin's modular synthesizer unseen ("a ghost performer") during some of the Phil & Ned sets. But could there really have been long stretches of this show where no one onstage was doing anything at all? Who knows. 

re: the section with Phil Lesh (34-46 min): this sounds very clearly to me like Lesh's bass, both played normally (i.e. how it sounded live with the Dead ca 1973-74) and then fed through some synth effect (unlike with the Dead, but it still clearly sounds like Lesh). But apparently he was only mixing, so this must be a pre-recorded tape. Heard blind, though, it sounds very much like Lesh is playing this live in real time. So who knows.

One thing that's extremely striking is Jerry's dramatic use a delay effect (an echoplex), which as far as I can recall, isn't an effect he ever used with the Dead. When he gets going with the echoplex, his wahwah, and playing slide guitar -- that's about as good as it gets. I know that!

appendix: Seastones the album(s)

This post was a good opportunity for me to come to a better understanding of Seastones as a composition/project, so I am just putting this here for my own sake. My understanding of Seastones the composition is that it is both a written-down piece of music with a form and parameters (i.e. there's a score), and also a philosophical approach to process. By design, there is both a Seastones on paper and also as many Seastones as there are performances of Seastones (okay, fine, one could argue the same thing about, I dunno, Pachelbel's Canon or something, but let's stay in one lane here). Lagin's website lays out the nitty gritty, so I won't rehash all that here. But the confusing history of Seastones on record is worth untangling. There was a 1972 album (still unreleased) that was rejected by Warner Bros. A later version was finalized in Feb 1975 and released on the 1975 Round Records LP, tracked into ten sections ("moment forms"). The 1990 Rykodisc cd reissue included both a later version (Dec 1975) plus the Round Records version, now remixed (both versions were tracked as single pieces) but also, as Backstrom points out (287), slightly edited from the LP version. Lagin's 2018 self-released CD release featured the remixed components of all prior versions plus additional material (83 tracks total!), intended to be played in any order. [4]  One such assemblage of a few of those tracks were released as a 2020 LP Seastones Set 4 and Set 5. May the moment-forms keep on coming! But don't think too hard about any of this stuff while driving.

sage advice, courtesy Nedbase. And in case you're wondering: no it didn't.

footnotes

[1] I was dismayed to see myself quoted in one of Backstrom's footnotes (on p. 248), talking out of my ass, in a post to a now-defunct GD forum that had maybe a dozen active members. In the spirit of Seastones, I can only offer that that misinformed post was a moment-form timescape that has since accreted new understandings.

[2] From Santokh's 2024 obituary: he was "one of the managers of the Grateful Dead and develop[ed] a close friendship with lead guitarist and singer Jerry Garcia. [He] was with the Grateful Dead when they performed at Woodstock and at Altamont […] In 1987, with the support of Jerry Garcia, Bob Weir, Ram Dass, and others, he launched Creating Our Future (COF), a social action training organization..."  From his own website's bio: he was "one of the primary organizers of the Summer of Love concerts in Golden Gate park" and "a manager of the Grateful Dead."  This article has more info about his time with the Dead (um, that's him getting beat up by the Hells Angels with the pool cues in Gimme Shelter!? wtf). Light Into Ashes also dropped a few more crumbs about his connection to the Dead re the 1968 "firing" and the 2/19/69 Celestial Synapse show (hey now). 

[3] Lagin spoke several times about wanting to play an unseen, sometimes unheard role in the music. This pic of him behind the wall of sound is one of the funnier Dead photos I've seen:

7/21/74; photo by ultomatt, from Nedbase

[4] All accounts of Lagin's story say that he walked away from the GD in mid 1975, but the 2018 Seastones cd credits mention that some additional material was recorded sometime between 1975-1977 with - waaait for it - Owsley Stanley!